Comic Relief has said it will carry out a review of its investment policy after being accused of investing millions of pounds in funds with shares in tobacco, alcohol and arms firms.
The claims were made in a BBC Panorama investigation broadcast on Tuesday night. It alleges that the charity, which received donations worth over £100m in 2013, has invested £630,000 in arms manufacturer BAE Systems. This is despite Comic Relief’s mission statement pledging to help those “affected by conflict“.
The programme revealed that Comic Relief also invested in British American Tobacco and had more than £300,000 invested in the alcohol industry, even though the charity says it is working to “minimise alcohol related harm”.
Comic Relief chief executive Kevin Cahill told BBC Radio 4’s World at One show on Tuesday that no more than 5% of its funds were going into these controversial areas.
“The trustees, I think, believe that the decisions they have made have delivered the greatest benefits to our beneficiaries”, he insisted.
Last week, when the BBC announced they would be airing the programme, the charity insisted that it had “nothing to hide”, saying that everything it was doing was legal.
Cahill has now said that Comic Relief and similar organisations should ask for advice from the Charity Commission on the matter “because there seems to be some room for doubt”.
Charities are legally required to seek the best financial return with their investments, although in certain circumstances they can opt out of this. Charity Commission guidance, published in 2011, says, “The law permits the following reasons [for investing ethically, even if lower returns are anticipated]: a particular investment conflicts with the aims of the charity; or the charity might lose supporters or beneficiaries if it does not invest ethically; or there is no significant financial detriment.”
Jane Tully, head of policy and public affairs at the Charity Finance Group (CFG), explained, “Ethical investment is a tricky area for many [charities] as they’ll need to strike a balance between risk and return.”
She added, “[Charities] should also consider the fact that the public expect them to be good and responsible investors. Investing in a way that conflicts with what they do, or damages their reputation may harm their mission and have long-term impacts on donors’ willingness to give – a loss of support that may ultimately undermine the financial return generated anyway.”
Comic Relief has previously argued that using ethical screening would have left it subject to unacceptable financial risk. However, after being told ethical funds have recently outperformed their mainstream counterparts, Cahill said, “It’s very good to hear that, in fact, the potential exists within ethical funds to match the return because Comic Relief would clearly choose to be in those if the return was equal or better to where we currently are so it’s a no brainer for us to be in those funds.”
Nick O’Donohoe, chief executive of Big Society Capital, said that the revelations “[highlight] the importance for all organisations, but particularly charities, to understand where their investments are being made.”
He added, “At a minimum they should ensure investment managers have active engagement in environmental, social and governance issues and should be encouraging their investment managers to sign the United Nations Principles for Responsible Investment.”
Like our Facebook Page
Eco-Friendly Decisions That Will Enhance Your Quality of Life
List of Fantastic Places for Green Consumers to Settle in South Carolina
6 Amazing Eco-Friendly Bedroom Design Ideas for Sustainable Homeowners
5 Great Ways to be a More Environmentally-Friendly Cannabis User
Amazing Approaches to Cycling for Promoting a Greener Lifestyle
Understanding The True Environmental Impact of Dentistry
Incredibly Important Benefits of Effective Ethically Made Anti-Virus Face Masks
Best Natural and Eco-Friendly Ways to Treat Dog Ailments
Green Entrepreneurs Find Creative Ways to Balance Ethical Goals with their Retirement Objectives
The Surprising Environmental Benefits of Using an Organic Mattress
From Store to Door with Minimal Impact: How Companies Are Eco-Friendly Innovators
A Guide to Investing In Renewable Energy Stocks in 2021
Creative Ideas to Practice Eco-friendlier Consumerism
Hawkers Launch a Truly Innovative Eco-Friendly Sunglass Line
Everything You Need to Know Before You Start Using Renewable Energy in 2021
The Curtis Institute of Music Makes Facilities More Energy Efficient
What Can Ecotourists Learn from Visiting Chernobyl?
5 Essentials for Promising Eco-Friendly Businesses to Thrive in a New Economy
Charity Organizations Who Are Taking Steps to Become More Environmentally Friendly
Mastering the Art of Trading Bitcoins Profitably and Sustainably
- Editors Choice12 months ago
10 Green Companies With Amazing Environmental Initiatives
- Features12 months ago
5 Sustainable Home Improvement Ideas To Improve Your Home’s Value
- Energy12 months ago
10 Amazing Energy Saving Hacks for Spring
- Invest11 months ago
4 Super Simple Solutions To Create The Perfect Eco-Friendly Home