Features

Ed Miliband’s Bedford speech heavy on rhetoric, weak on action

Published

11 years ago

February 16, 2013

Simon Leadbetter

With a 3,330 word speech on Thursday, Ed Miliband managed only one mention of ‘green’ and ‘clean’ but no mentions of renewables, climate or the environment. Faced with the greatest existential threat to our way of life, British politicians remain stubbornly timid about making the case for a genuinely sustainable economy and lag behind public and business opinion.

Miliband’s speech was ostensibly about living standards. He argued that a race to the bottom in terms of salaries and conditions was not a sensible economic strategy. The economic rights and wrongs of his address are for other commentators, except for one thing. The glaring omission of climate change and its critical impact on our economy’s future, and the people who live in it, is a staggering oversight. There is no economic stability without a stable environment.

Each budget and party conference season, we listen to speeches laden with self-serving and narrow patriotism, misinformed statements about society’s ills and dogmatic proposals for economic growth. We never hear enough about the real and immediate action that needs to be undertaken to create a genuinely sustainable economy.

As our recent infographic illustrated, the population overwhelmingly supports a significant expansion in renewable energy.

Innovation is disruptive. Innovative businesses fail fast and often. Innovation is inefficient but creates new investment and jobs. Often these innovators need government support to displace established industries. Clean technology generally and renewable energy specifically represent an unrivalled growth opportunity for our uniquely innovative country.

While mastering solar energy should probably be left to sunnier climes, we can be masters at wind, wave and tidal energy. Micro-generation and small-scale hydro projects on our many rivers would give communities much need investment and cheap energy. Not only could we create energy security but also build a valuable export industry. This would be a huge bonus economically and ecologically.

Insulating and retrofitting energy saving devices to our homes and businesses would be a boost for tradespeople and manual workers; Miliband’s forgotten 50%. This would be a huge bonus economically and ecologically.

There are always those who worry about climate change fatigue if politicians ‘bang on’ about climate change, but that’s like people in the early 1940s worrying about Nazi-fatigue during the second world war.

Climate change represents a clear and present danger to our economy and society. If you do not believe that is the case then you really need to read more science and a lot less uninformed, unscientific opinion. Especially those who say things like, “It is not my job” to read peer reviewed papers, but instead to be “an interpreter of interpretations”.

It is time for all of our political leaders to make the strongest case for the long-term sustainability of our economy, and rapid action. This means balancing the viability of the planet and the need for greater global prosperity, often crudely and incorrectly measured by GDP.

Miliband makes a compelling argument for a more equal society, which all the evidence points to as being happier, healthier and more at ease with itself, but the triple pillars of sustainability need to be tackled today.

But, our living standards are threatened by climate change more than anything else.

In 1966, Kenneth E Boulding, in Frank F Darling and John P Milton’s Future Environments of North America, wrote the following: “With laissez-faire and price atomic, ecology’s uneconomic, But with another kind of logic economy’s unecologic.”

The planet cannot wait.

Simon Leadbetter is the founder and publisher of Blue & Green Tomorrow. He has held senior roles at Northcliffe, The Daily Telegraph, Santander, Barclaycard, AXA, Prudential and Fidelity. In 2004, he founded a marketing agency that worked amongst others with The Guardian, Vodafone, E.On and Liverpool Victoria. He sold this agency in 2006 and as Chief Marketing Officer for two VC-backed start-ups launched the online platform Cleantech Intelligence (which underpinned the The Guardian’s Cleantech 100) and StrategyEye Cleantech. Most recently, he was Marketing Director of Emap, the UK’s largest B2B publisher, and the founder of Blue & Green Communications Limited.