The government has published new laws that give voters the ability to recall their MPs, but critics say the bill is “meaningless” as it keeps powers in the hands of politicians.
The bill, published on Thursday, rules that an MP can be recalled if they are convicted of an offence and receive a sentence of 12 months or less, or if House of Commons authorities suspend them for at least 21 sitting days.
In such a scenario, constituents would be given the option of signing a recall petition. If 10% of voters sign and a committee of MPs agreed, a byelection would be held.
Under pre-existing rules, MPs are only automatically ejected from parliament if they are jailed for more than 12 months.
“The bill puts in place a recall mechanism for MPs which is transparent, robust and fair,” deputy prime minister Nick Clegg said in a statement.
“It strikes a fair balance between holding to account those who do not maintain certain standards of conduct, while giving MPs the freedom to do their job and make difficult decisions where necessary.”
All three of the major Westminster parties promised to put forward such laws ahead of the last general election, and the bill was finally announced in this year’s Queen’s speech.
However, critics say that in its current form the bill has been unacceptably watered down from the original proposals, with some questioning whether any MP would ever be unseated under the new laws.
A group of 22 MPs from seven parties, lead by Conservative MP Zac Goldsmith, have instead put forward an alternative bill.
The private member’s bill, which was formed in part by a survey of 40,000 members of the public, would mean an MP could be recalled if 5% of voters in a constituency sign a “notice of intent to recall” and 20% of voters signed a subsequent “recall petition“.
Ultimately, the power would no longer lie with MPs.
“Recall is supposed to be about empowering voters to hold their MPs to account, and the government’s proposals fall scandalously short. They don’t empower voters in any meaningful sense at all, and at the very first scandal, they will realise they have been duped,” Goldsmith said.
“We have formally tabled the bill, and will use it as the basis for radical amendment of the government’s version.”
Tory MP David Davis, the former shadow home secretary and another supporter of the alternative bill, added, “Genuine recall is critical to build the reputation and credibility of parliament. And so it is appropriate that we create a recall law that is produced with the public and MPs working alongside each other.”
In a survey by Blue & Green Tomorrow and Vote for Policies, published in the Guide to Sustainable Democracy, 93% of 6,999 respondents said a genuine recall bill would strengthen the UK’s democracy. Only 2% said it would weaken it.
Like our Facebook Page
Solar-Powered Solutions for Lowering City Infrastructure Carbon Footprint
How to Prioritize Sustainability When Studying Abroad
EHS Management is Making the Construction Industry Greener
Best Sustainable Practices in the Construction Industry in 2024
Comparing Renewable Energy: Solar Power, Wind, Hydro & Bio
Maximizing Home Efficiency: The Renewable Way
10 Easy Ways To Make Your Home More Eco-Friendly
Energy Management Mastery: 4 Tips for Green Property Owners
Wonderful Ways to Make Your University Lifestyle Greener
How Construction Companies Can Ensure Sustainable Practices
How To Track The Carbon Footprint of Your eCommerce Orders?
Insider Tips for an Eco-Friendly Dubai Vacation in 2024
The Coming Social & Environmental Challenges of eCommerce
How You Can Cool Your Home Without Warming the Planet
Polythene Bags and Food Safety: Crucial Role in Food Packaging
How Can Field Service Companies Reduce Their Carbon Footprint?
Solo Eco-Tourism Misconceptions That Need To Be Debunked
5 Tips for Creating a Sustainable Living Space
Embracing Sustainability: 7 Tips for Eco-Friendly Shopping
Crypto Market Makers Are Becoming More Eco-Friendly
- Features8 months ago
What is the Eco-Friendliest Option to Wash Your Dishes?
- Environment12 months ago
6 Home Improvements You Can Make to Help the Environment
- Editors Choice11 months ago
7 Tips to Minimize the Negative Impact Businesses Have on the Environment
- Environment12 months ago
The Truth About The Environmental Impact of Dogs