Anti-smoking campaigners have rejected Hackney council’s defence of £10.5m pension fund investments in tobacco stocks.
Last year, the council declared that its pension funds had a “duty” to invest in tobacco. These claims have since been called into question by a new report from FairPensions and anti-smoking charity ASH.
According to the council’s own figures, about £10.5m of its pension funds are in tobacco stocks including British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco. Many analysts have predicted the complete demise of smoking based on decreasing sales figures around the world, and the report questions whether tobacco is an economical long-term investment.
Hackney council is defending its decision to pump public money into tobacco firms just as Kent county council may have to withdraw millions of pounds invested in tobacco companies.
A total of £24m is said to be tied up in tobacco firms by the council – the exact same figure that we reported in February was invested in the industry by Cornwall council.
Due to be discussed at a forthcoming meeting, the council said that this particular investment – which is shared between four global producers – provided a “difficult ethical balance”.
Both Hackney and Kent councils have specified that they believe this provides the best return for its members. This seems to ignore the many health issues from smoking and passive smoking.
Shops and supermarkets, as of April 6 this year, are required to cover up cigarettes and hide tobacco products from public view following new legislation.
Martin Dockrell, director of research and policy at ASH says, “Pension fund holders can’t seem to shake their addiction to tobacco shares but today’s nicotine rush looks set to be followed by withdrawal symptoms tomorrow.
“These shares are widely rated by analysts as over-valued. With sales volumes declining in key markets and increased tax, regulation and worldwide litigation in the pipeline, there has never been a better time to kick the habit.
“There is no obligation to invest in the tobacco industry.”
Many councils that have found themselves under the microscope for their questionable pension scheme investment portfolios have attempted to dodge the bullet by claiming they just wanted good profits for investors. But Dockrell adds that there is a solution.
“There is an easy answer known as the ‘ethical tie break’”, he explains.
“Adopt a policy where the presumption is that if investments have broadly equal value, fund managers should opt for the non-tobacco share.
“That way, managers only invest in tobacco when they can demonstrate that no other share offers equal value.”
It could be argued that only a small percentage of a council’s portfolio is dedicated to investing in tobacco, but as Cornwall councillor Alex Folkes translated in a blog post, only a small percentage were “investing in death” – providing a contrasting view of the nature of the investments.
Our recent Guide to Sustainable Investment should provide more-than-enough background on the topic of investing with a conscience. We urge you to read it and be inspired.
Like our Facebook Page
The Pros and Cons of Fixed Prices for Sustainable Energy
How to Plan an Unforgettable Eco-Friendly Trip to Europe
Is Decarbonizing The Shipping Industry an Achievable Goal?
Designing Eco-Systems Sustainable Exhibits: Strategies for Reducing Environmental Impact
Green Living, Education and Awareness Are Keys to Preventing Mesothelioma
Canada Can Take New Steps to Make Healthcare Greener
Roy Bartholomew Shares Basics of Ecosystem Engineering
Understanding the Evolving Science of Environmental Health
Is Eco-Friendly Composite Decking Really Good for the Planet?
Eco-Friendly Composting Tips that All Gardeneners Should Follow
6 Home Improvements You Can Make to Help the Environment
Reduce, Reuse, Recycle: Eco-Friendly Party Favors Made for the Garden
One of the Most Unique Eco-Friendly Travel Tips: Try Rollerblading
Humane Pigeons Pest Control Tips Environmentalists Can Follow
Environmental Impact of Artificial Grass for Your Lawn
Choosing The Best Eco-Friendly Furniture Set for your Living Room
Planning an Eco-Friendly Bus Trip to Singapore with Friends
How to Travel More Sustainably While Saving Money
The Truth About The Environmental Impact of Dogs
6 Major Luxury Residential Projects Responding to Climate Change
- Energy10 months ago
How To Choose the Right Solar Inverter for Your Home?
- Energy11 months ago
How to Choose the Best Solar Panel for Your Home
- Environment11 months ago
Reduce Industry Footprints with Sustainable Material Swaps
- Environment10 months ago
Is Smart Building Technology the Future of Sustainability?